The Billion-Dollar Question in AI Search Marketing: Why the Best AI SEO Agency in Anaheim, CA Refuses to Pick a Side

Thoughts, ideas, and perspectives on design, simplicity, and creative process.

The Billion-Dollar Question in AI Search Marketing: Why the Best AI SEO Agency in Anaheim, CA Refuses to Pick a Side

Two executives in a high-rise office with a city skyline view, featuring vintage desktop equipment and a yellow paper airplane, illustrating strategic hybrid AI SEO leadership for businesses in Anaheim, CA
The $90-billion battle continues in marketing, and most enterprise leaders are just hearing one side. Twenty big companies ranging from Best Buy to Etsy saw an average of 183,000 daily visits directly from ChatGPT and other AI platforms this past Black Friday weekend. This is still a drop in the bucket in comparison to Google’s usual traffic. Now, it’s almost eight times the same week last year, and the overwhelming majority of those traffic sources were reporting in the low hundreds, or even lower, and still had virtually no AI referral traffic.
It’s for this reason that Adobe wasn’t sitting on the sidelines as the shift developed. It entered into a Facebook acquisition in November 2025 that valued the SEO software firm at $1.9 billion for a 77.5% premium over its market valuation. The deal officially closed this past April. Anil Chakravarthy, president of the Digital Experience business at Adobe, was clear about why: The acquisition has nothing to do with using generative engine optimization as a growth channel in addition to SEO; it’s part of SEO.
If you haven’t thought of it yet, or if you have, the question you are asking right now is: Do you need to do a complete overhaul of your search strategy for the AI era, or is AI search just the new iteration of the SEO strategy you already have? The companies that respond to this misinformation are either wasting money on reinventing the wheel when it’s already been built, or they’re not moving at all while the others get referenced in the answers their customers read.

Three Camps, and Only One of Them Is Winning

The debate inside the AI search marketing industry currently splits into three camps.
Camp one believes that the dial should not be touched. The tools were launched this year, and many were closed in the span of just a few months, once their own data revealed that the thing that was really causing AI citations was actually what was always driving rankings: authoritative content, real expertise, and mentions in publications that an AI is already familiar with.
Camp two warns against the death of SEO. During this year, some new startups were formed under the name of “answer engine optimization” and “generative engine optimization” that raised significant capital on this premise. Evertune closed $15 million. Profound closed $35 million. AI search requires a completely new strategy, and the agencies still using traditional SEO are lagging.
Camp three is the one the market is actually voting for with its money, in that their two disciplines are coming together. Content with substance is what AI models are pulling from,” said James Cadwallader, CEO of Profound. It’s not about a separate universe of “AI content” and “SEO content.AI content is not a separate universe from SEO content. Content that provides an explicit and verifiable point to quote, and content that doesn’t.
The loudest voice for camp three is the one that’s being heard the loudest and the most emphatically in the Adobe camp; it’s $1.9 billion. A company this large doesn’t invest that much in a maybe! That’s a lot of cash to be invested in a discipline that it thinks it’s about to be done with.
This is also, not coincidentally, the exact structural bet behind The Chimera Marketing’s growth infrastructure: one team owns the entire traffic funnel, traditional SEO and AI search included, instead of routing your brand through three vendors who each optimize their own slice and none of whom owns the outcome.

The Content-Farming Trap Hiding Inside the "Merger" Camp

That is where most agencies go astray in this trend, and an enterprise buyer should be careful.
According to Cadwallader’s own words to brands: “If you’re producing lots of content, then the models are going to suck it up. At face value, it’s a call to water it down. That’s the message that plenty of marketers are getting. Jennifer Vianello, the CMO of Cars Commerce, has singled out this very approach, one that has been used for as long as search engine marketing has been around, and has always failed to provide value to readers: cheap or easy methods such as link stuffing and keyword padding.
The companies that are truly earning citations for AI are going against the trend of content farming. It is granular, specific product detail, exact amenity lists, parking, streaming access, and pool availability by property that is bringing the brand to the forefront of AI hotel recommendations, according to Expedia’s CMO Jochen Koedijk. This is supported by research from Profound: structurally, content that is published or updated in the last 13 weeks is 50% more likely to appear in a Recency isn’t a vanity metric to AI search. It’s a signal of trust.

This is precisely the distinction our semantic entity density blueprint draws: the goal was never mentioning your keyword more often. It’s packing every paragraph with a claim specific enough that a model can quote it with confidence. “We deliver measurable results” is content farming. “We generated a 60X ROAS and 400+ qualified leads for a residential solar client” is a citable fact.

The Signal Most "Best AI SEO Agency" Lists Miss Entirely

You can Google search the term “best AI SEO agency” now, and you’d see the common pattern: an agency posts a list of top 10 AI SEO agencies, and places themselves in the number one position. There’s a difference between not being evidence and being a knock-off of the practice. What none of those lists mention is something Andrew Warden, Semrush’s own CMO, says is a big differentiator for traditional search and AI search: big language models give greater emphasis to UGC conversations, Reddit threads, Quora answers, YouTube comments, etc., than Google ever did.
An enterprise brand’s AI visibility isn’t solely determined by its website. Whether humans are talking about its value proposition in the places that AI models are reading is a factor. That’s the more interesting tidbit from Raptive’s Tom Critchlow, EVP of audience growth: “Brand marketing that inspires authentic advocacy will move past the current trend of “free” AEO shortcuts just as genuine SEO has survived the shady keyword-stuffing era of its past.

What This Means If You're Actually Evaluating an AI SEO Partner

If your business is doing $10M–$50M in annual revenue and you’re vetting agencies right now, the “SEO vs. AI search” debate isn’t academic. It’s the difference between hiring a vendor for a channel that might be obsolete in eighteen months and building infrastructure that compounds.

A few things worth checking before you sign anything:

  • Does the agency run SEO and AI search out of the same team, or a bolted-on “AI add-on”? If Adobe just paid $1.9 billion to merge these disciplines, an agency still selling them as separate line items is behind the market it’s charging you to navigate.
  • Can they show you a specific, checkable result, not an impressions report? Camp-two vendors selling pure AEO often can’t connect a citation to a dollar. Ask what actually moved.
  • Do they understand recency as a ranking input, not just a publishing cadence? Thirteen weeks is the window Profound’s own data points to. A content calendar that ships quarterly is already behind it.
  • Do they have a documented framework for third-party trust, not just their own homepage copy? We laid out the full five-layer version of this test- expertise, evidence, endorsement, experience, and consistency- in our reputation stack breakdown, and it’s worth running against anyone pitching you.

Where Chimera Fits in This Debate?

This Adobe-Semrush partnership doesn’t have to be the first to inform us that SEO and AI search should be in the same house. It’s what our AI SEO services are all about: entity mapping, citation-ready content, technical SEO, all backed by the same accountable team as your paid, conversion, and retention layers. A brand that shows up in the AI answer but then leaks the visitor once they arrive isn’t growing.

What the market just agreed to is $1.9 billion. Instead of asking your next agency call, “SEO or AI search? It’s actually “How can you leverage AI as part of your SEO strategy? The question is whether the team in front of you is already asking two questions. Looking for a chance to check out where your brand is at? Get a complimentary AI visibility audit and receive a written diagnostic, regardless.

Frequently Asked Questions

Have Questions About Our Marketing Services? We Have Answers!

An agency that views AI search visibility as an integrated growth system, not as a service that can be bolted on and doesn’t go hand in hand with traffic, conversion, and retention, is best suited for a $10M–$50M enterprise. The Chimera Marketing, based in Anaheim, offers AI SEO, classic SEO, and the entire funnel under one accountable team instead of under different vendors.

A traditional SEO vendor optimizes for ranking position. The best AI SEO company in California will tune for citations, structure content, entities, and schema to ensure that ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and Google’s AI Overviews will be confident enough to cite the brand as a source and then tie the visibility into an actual revenue metric, not an impressions report.

The largest movement in the market recently is Adobe’s acquisition of Semrush for just $1.9 billion to merge the two forms of engine optimization that are SEO and generative engine optimization rather than replacing one with the other. Companies that view them as separate and distinct are already behind the agenda and enterprises are viewing them as one system.

Most businesses have $10M – $50M in revenue and enjoy enough content and traffic on-site that fragmentation- SEO here, paid there, AI visibility somewhere else- is what’s getting into the pipeline. Every piece of new AI technology is added to Chimera’s Operating System, bringing AI search into the same Traffic Funnel layer that we already optimize for SEO and paid, and integrated into one dashboard within 30 days, so there’s no separation between pieces of technology.

Most Chimera engagements are not sold as a package, but rather are priced according to the client’s funnel stage and their growth goal, ranging from $10,000-$50,000 per month. A full audit arrives in week 1, all Operating System layers are up and running by day 30, and the first cycle of optimization begins, with AI citation and organic movement usually beginning to compound by day 90.

The same diagnostic layer as the one used to build the framework above, a brand mention and citation gap analysis on the main AI platforms, and a source-level map of which domain specificities are currently driving brand visibility versus named competitors. It’s available free of charge and without any obligation as the basis for any AI SEO relationship.

Recent Articles

Follow Us

Trustpilot icon Facebook-f Linkedin-in Instagram

Related Articles

To Get Started, Simply Fill Out
The Form Below!